Save to Buy Or Borrow and Buy

Two friends Mr Saver and Mr. Borrower just started working both earning $100 a month. Their dream was to own a car which was worth $500. Mr. Saver opened a super saver account with 8% interest per annum compounded monthly. He saved $25 from his salary every month for 11 months.

Mr. Borrower made a down payment of $25 took a loan of $475 at 8% per annum for 5years.

Mr. Saver made a down payment of $311 after saving for 11 months he actually saved $300 rest $11 was interest earned and took a loan of $189 at 8% per annum for 2years.

Now let’s do some maths.

For Mr. Borrower the car of $500 will actually cost

$577.8 (total amount that he has to return on the $475 loan) + $25 = $603

When he makes monthly payment of $9.633 for 5 years

For Mr Saver the car of $500 will cost

$300+ $205(total amount that he has to return on the $189 loan) = $505

When he makes monthly payment of $8.55 for 2 years

The car for Mr. Saver costs $98 less he finishes his loan in 2years paying less amount per month in installments than Mr. Borrower. Also since car is a losing investment i.e. its value will always go down with time. So if you pay more you end up loosing more.

Alas for all the saving talk I still can’t save a penny. If only we could practice what we preach life would be lot better :).

Comments

Unknown said…
Classic example of 'Delayed Gratification' well illustrated. However another school of thought says Mr Borrower enjoyed the Car 1 year more and earlier than Mr Saver..Carpe Diem :)
Sanj said…
you still not at wrongs dude, as it's passable not to have anything saved but a sin when you know you have thousands stacked up your sleeve to pay to the dim banks...

Popular Posts